Showing posts with label divorce agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label divorce agreement. Show all posts

Sunday, July 26, 2009

Marital Settlement Agreements

The New Jersey court was recently asked to decide whether a document between a divorcing couple hand written by a mediator, initialed as to each paragraph by the couple but not signed was a valid agreement for purposes of a marital settlement agreement. The appellate court answered in the affirmative.

In the case of Hasty vs. Hasty, the couple both tenured professors at Ivy League universities voluntarily decided to attend a mediation session accompanied by their respective attorneys. At the conclusion of a four hour mediation session, the mediator who was a retired superior court judge in private practice, prepared a handwritten three page document entitled, “Hasty Agreement.” The document clearly detailed in nine paragraphs the separation and division of the couple’s assets and liabilities; the distribution of furniture and the waiver of alimony. The couple initialed each paragraph of the document.

Subsequently, one of the attorneys prepared a more detailed marital settlement agreement containing additional boilerplate clauses which wasn’t accepted by the husband. The wife thereafter filed the divorce complaint and requested the court to honor the mediation document. The husband asserted in his affidavit that he wasn’t aware that the mediation document was a valid settlement agreement and sought to have the document disregarded by the court.

However, the court rejected the husband’s assertions and found that the mediation document was a binding agreement between the couple because it was initialed by both as to each paragraph and the document was labeled an agreement. The absence of signatures was not considered a fatal flaw in the agreement. The court reasoned that even oral agreements are binding on individuals if there was intent by the individuals to be bound. The court determined that the document raised and resolved all the major issues between the couple in comprehensive terms. Furthermore, the court noted that the husband for several months after the mediation meeting complied with the terms and actions required of him by the agreement.

In divorce mediation, a couple through the assistance of a skilled divorce mediator attempts to agree on the various issues affecting them such as, alimony, allocation of assets and liabilities, child custody and visitation. At the conclusion of the mediation sessions the divorce mediator would prepare a settlement agreement, usually a Memorandum of Understanding or (some mediators will prepare) a Marital Settlement Agreement. Usually, the prepared document is presented to the divorcing couple for their and if they choose their attorney’s review. Thereafter, if no revisions are required, the divorcing couple would sign the agreement and have it filed with the court. In the Hasty’s case, it is unclear why the retired judge in private practice would have the couple initial each paragraph yet omit signatures. Nor is it clear why there wasn't additional verbiage in the agreement detailing the couple's voluntary concurrence of the terms and in the presence of their attorneys.

Monday, July 13, 2009

Disability Insurance in Divorce Agreements

In divorce proceedings and negotiations, if permanent or limited duration alimony, as well as child support is a component of the possible settlement agreement, life insurance for the benefit of the dependent spouse and children is a consideration and usually made part of the paying spouse’s continued obligation. In fact, the New Jersey Legislature has specifically allowed for life insurance to be ordered by the judge to protect the dependent spouse in case of premature death of the payer spouse under N.J.S.A. 2A:35-25. The theory behind this additional insurance premium burden upon the payer spouse is that the untimely death of the payer spouse should not become the burden of society to support the dependent spouse and children. However, there are no requirements regarding disability insurance in divorce settlements. A payer spouse is not under any obligation to obtain and maintain a disability insurance policy for the benefit of the dependant spouse or children. However, NJ Family Law & Divorce Mediation strongly encouages inclusion of disability insurance as part of an overall divorce settlement.

Disability insurance is a voluntary insurance policy which pays monthly benefits to the insured if he or she becomes disabled by a covered risk and will still pay only a portion of the injured spouse’s gross employment earnings. We’re all familiar with the commercial of the quacking duck exclaiming AFLAC to all that would listen, yet most people don’t have disability insurance. Those few who have coverage seem to acquire it through their employers. Since the legislature failed to include provisions for disability insurance protection for the dependant spouse and there are no New Jersey divorce court cases which deal squarely with this issue, NJ divorce attorneys representing payer spouses generally do not allow a disability insurance provision to be included in the divorce settlement agreement. The failure of NJ divorce attorneys to look long term for their clients real needs may be a detriment to their clients.

The consequences of not having a disability insurance policy in place on the payer spouse could cause severe economic hardship to both spouses and their children. Generally, when an individual becomes disabled because of a non work related injury such as by a medical condition; heart attack, stroke, cancer to name a few disabling illnesses, the payer spouse’s recourse is to seek Social Security disability benefits. These benefits only provide for a small fraction of the payer spouse’s prior employment income. The reduced funds available to the payer and dependent spouse are further burdened by the likelihood of increased medical bills.

Insurance is always a gamble. Premiums are paid for coverage for a possible future occurrence. In some instances, government requires us to purchase certain types of insurance such as liability coverage on our automobiles in case we damage property or inflict injury upon someone. In other matters, our mortgage lender requires fire and casualty homeowner’s insurance should the house catch fire or is damaged by harsh winds. With the long term view toward protection and stability, divorcing couples and their respective attorneys should seriously consider the possibility that the payer spouse may become disabled during the alimony and child support obligation periods.

Although a payer spouse may be reluctant to pay additional insurance premiums for the benefit of his ex-spouse, there is a strong possibility that the payer spouse would look more favorability to providing protection and stability to the children and himself. Disability insurance is affordable and can be obtained in different coverage amounts, such as the amount equal to the cost of the monthly child support payment or just the cost of the monthly alimony obligation. Disability insurance must be a topic for discussion during the active divorce settlement talks so that the divorcing couple may fully understand the possible future scenarios which can adversely affect them. At Montclair Divorce Mediation, the discussion of disability insurance for the protection of the family is part of the framework for divorcing clients to consider incorporating into their divorce agreement.

Friday, June 26, 2009

After a Divorce Who Claims the Child as a Tax Exemption?

The appellate court in today's divorce decision of Canavan, Jr. vs. Canavan, restated two known maxims that every divorce lawyer and their client better remember: read the fine print and know the law. In the case of Michael and Elisabeth Canavan, Jr., the couple had a five year old daughter when they divorced in 2007. As part of their divorce settlement agreement, the child was to reside with her mother, Elisabeth. The parties could not agree on who was going to claim the child as a tax exemption so the issue was not addressed in their Property Settlement Agreement and final divorce judgment. Within a year of the divorce, the father went back to court to be able to claim the child as an exemption in alternating years. The trial court initially agreed with the father, then thereafter, reconsidered and sided with the mother. An appeal was filed and the appellate court reviewed the applicable divorce law and divorce settlement agreement. The court first identified that the IRS Code grants the custodial parent the exemption unless that parent waives the exemption. In this case, Elisabeth being the custodial parent never waived the exemption. The court then reviewed the couple's multi-page divorce settlement agreement which contained the clause, "no issues were unresolved in this matter and all issues pleaded and not proven are deemed abandoned." As a result of not resolving the issue and the insertion of this clause, Michael, the father, was thereafter precluded from seeking the exemption. The moral of the story, resolve all the issues before signing the agreement and always read the fine print. At Montclair Divorce Mediation, we ensure that the divorcing couple reads and understands the full divorce settlement agreement.

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Pets & Divorce

Who gets the family pet is an important topic to NJ divorcing couples. Although pet owners develop strong bonds with their pets, referring to them as their “babies”, N.J. judges are reluctant to deal with the custody of the pets. Often, judges felt it was a waste of court time and would not entertain the notion of hearing arguments of who better cared for the family dog. NJ Courts have traditionally considered pets as property and as such, they were only worth the value of economic replacement, similar to replacing a television or other object. However, in a divorce decision this year, the appellate court while still considering a pet as property likened the family dog to possible family heirloom status, whereby money can’t replace the full sentimental value attached to the pet. What this means is that the trial court will now have to deal with the family pet issue, but divorcing couples should not expect the court to consider custody issues. Rather, the NJ divorce court may value the pet greater than its simple economic value or force one person to give up the pet if the couple had a prior agreement. Couples can amicably resolve the pet issue along with other issues by divorce mediation rather than costly divorce litigation. At Montclair Divorce Mediation, couples discuss the various aspects of whether joint shared pet custody is best for them, the specific time sharing arrangements and costs are then incorporated into their divorce settlement agreement. The more that couples can agree on outside of court, the better it is for them and their family.